Skip to main content

Table 1 Themes and Subthemes

From: Using a combination of cognitive behavioral therapy, case management and eHealth components for patients with depression or panic disorders in primary care practices in Hesse, Germany: an exploration of healthcare professionals’ lived experiences

Key theme

Facilitator

Barrier

Study instruction materials

Paper-based information: sufficient, well prepared, easy to understand, mainly used for review and repetition of topics

Paper-based information: too complex, limited time resources

Digital information: general satisfaction with the materials, including the interpersonal helpdesk provided by Embloom

Digital information: time-consuming, too text-heavy, access and log-in difficulties, lack of training

 

Overall: lack of collegial exchange, limited human interaction

Individual components of the treatment program

Combination of face-to-face consultation and online platform was most helpful, structured approach of the treatment program enabled regularity and continuity, and increased openness among patients

Patient screening results were not always in agreement with previous diagnosis

New responsibility for MAs was monitoring phone calls, which provided continuous patient care without direct involvement of the GP

Patients felt unsupported in performing anxiety exercises independently at home, and standardized/repeated questions reduced patient attention and reflection during monitoring phone calls

Practicality

MAs’ professional skills and their role as a central point of contact for patients in order to support GPs and ensure the implementation and feasibility of the study

Time-consuming organization and planning of monitoring telephone calls and GP consultations, limited time, personnel and spatial resources

Target population

No age limit; suitable for patients with mild or moderate depression and for patients’ waiting for psychotherapeutic treatment; conscientiousness; technical expertise available

Unsuitable for older patients, and those with negative attitudes towards technological tools

Benefits of the treatment program

Free and low-threshold access to online platform, remote utilization, easy entry into therapy, strengthening the MA-patient relationship, and empowering patient engagement in self-care

Use of online platform by itself is insufficient, in-person conversations are preferred, and not everyone is capable of using online applications